FRQ 1 · AAQ · one study, six parts, seven points

The Article Analysis Question

You read a summary of one real study and answer six short parts about how it was done and what it found. The study changes every year. The six tasks do not, so this is the most learnable seven points on the exam.

  • 7 pointsParts A to E are 1 each; Part F is 2
  • 25 minutesAbout 10 to read, 15 to write
  • 1 sourceIntro, participants, method, results
  • ≈16% of your scoreHalf of Section II

What AP is looking for

Research methods and design

Name the method the study used, state how a variable was measured, spot the ethical guidelines the researchers followed, and judge who the results apply to. This is Parts A, B, D, and E.

Data interpretation

Say what a number means for the study: which group was higher or lower, what direction a correlation runs, and whether a difference was statistically significant. This is Part C.

Argumentation

Use a specific result as evidence and explain how it supports or refutes the hypothesis or a psychology concept. This is Part F, and it is the only part worth 2 points.

The task verbs

Identify and state mean name it, no explanation needed. Describe means give the relevant features, tied to the study. Explain means say how or why, using evidence and reasoning. Readers score exactly the verb in the prompt.

Your 25-minute routine

  1. 0:00 to 1:00Read the six prompts first. Circle the variable named in B, the statistic named in C, and the hypothesis or concept named in F. Now you know what to hunt for.
  2. 1:00 to 10:00Read and mark the study. Box the groups or conditions and how participants got into them. Underline how each variable was measured. Star ethics words (consent, withdraw, debrief, review board, deception). Bracket who the participants were. Circle the key numbers in the results.
  3. 10:00 to 22:00Write A to F in order, labeled. Complete sentences, one short paragraph each. Start most answers with "In this study..." so every answer is tied to the source.
  4. 22:00 to 25:00Check. Did you name only one method and only the guidelines the study states? Does C say what the number means? Does E name a population and give participant details? Does F have a specific result and an explanation?

Worked example: Testing vs. Restudying

Show or hide the studyRead this once. Every sample answer on this page is about it.

A practice study written for this page, modeled on published research on the testing effect. Every scored example below answers questions about it.

Introduction

Researchers tested the hypothesis that practicing retrieval (taking a practice test) improves long-term retention more than restudying the same material. This pattern is called the testing effect.

Participants

One hundred twenty undergraduates (ages 18 to 22; 78 women and 42 men) enrolled in an introductory psychology course at one public university in Missouri took part for course credit. Before the study began, each participant read and signed a consent form that described the procedures and stated that they could withdraw at any time without losing credit.

Method

Participants were randomly assigned to one of two conditions. Everyone read a 250-word passage about sea otters for 7 minutes. Next, the restudy group read the passage again for 7 minutes, and the practice-test group spent 7 minutes writing down everything they could remember about it, with no feedback. Half of each group took a final test 5 minutes later; the other half returned one week later.

On the final test, participants wrote down everything they remembered. Recall was the percentage of the passage's 30 key ideas that a participant wrote down, scored by two raters who did not know which condition the participant was in. At the end of the session, participants were told the purpose of the study.

Results
Final testRestudy: mean recallPractice test: mean recall
After 5 minutes81%75%
After 1 week42%56%

After one week, the practice-test group recalled significantly more than the restudy group (p < .01). After 5 minutes, the restudy group recalled slightly more, but the difference was not statistically significant.

Discussion

The researchers concluded that retrieving information strengthens memory over time, even though restudying can feel more effective in the moment.

A

Research method

1 point

Identify the research method used in the study.

Identify: name it. One method, the right one.

What earns it

  • Names the method the study actually used: experiment, correlational study, case study, naturalistic observation, survey, or meta-analysis.
  • A short reason is fine and helps you check yourself ("...because participants were randomly assigned to conditions").

What doesn't

  • Naming a different method, or naming two methods ("an experiment and a correlational study"). The second one contradicts the first.
  • Describing the topic instead of the method ("They studied memory").
  • Naming only a design feature ("random assignment," "double-blind") without naming the method.

How to approach it

  1. Ask: did the researchers manipulate something and put people into groups at random? If yes, it is an experiment.
  2. If they only measured two variables as they naturally occur and looked for a relationship (look for r = ), it is correlational.
  3. One person or a small group in depth is a case study; watching behavior in its natural setting without interfering is naturalistic observation; combining many earlier studies is a meta-analysis.
  4. Write one sentence. Do not hedge between two methods.

Sentence frames

  • The researchers used a(n) ________ .
  • This study is a(n) ________ because the researchers ________ (randomly assigned participants to ___ / measured the relationship between ___ and ___).

Scored examples

  • Full credit · 1 of 1
    “The researchers used an experiment, because participants were randomly assigned to either restudy the passage or take a practice test.”

    Names the correct method, and the reason matches the study.

  • No credit · 0 of 1
    “The researchers used random assignment to put students into two groups.”

    Random assignment is a feature of experiments, but the response never names the method. The 2025 readers did not award this.

  • No credit · 0 of 1
    “This was an experiment and also a correlational study because they compared recall over time.”

    Naming a second, wrong method contradicts the correct one.

B

Operational definition

1 point

State the operational definition of recall.

State: give the measurable definition, as the study measured it.

What earns it

  • Says exactly how the variable was measured or manipulated in this study: the task, the unit, the scale, the count.
  • Uses the numbers and labels from the summary (a 1 to 7 scale, the number of errors, the percentage of key ideas).

What doesn't

  • A dictionary definition of the concept ("Recall is retrieving information without cues").
  • A vague description that could not be measured ("how much they remembered").
  • Defining the wrong variable, or describing the conditions when the prompt asked about the outcome.

How to approach it

  1. Find the sentence in the method that says how the variable was measured. It usually has a number, a scale, or a count in it.
  2. Rewrite it in your own sentence with every measurable detail: what was counted, out of what, and how.
  3. Test it: could another researcher run the study again from your sentence alone? If not, add the missing detail.

Sentence frames

  • In this study, ________ was operationally defined as ________ (the number / percentage / score on ___, measured by ___).
  • ________ was measured by ________ , on a scale from ___ to ___ .

Scored examples

  • Full credit · 1 of 1
    “Recall was operationally defined as the percentage of the passage’s 30 key ideas that a participant wrote down on the final test.”

    Measurable and specific to the study: what was counted (key ideas), out of what (30), and how (written on the final test).

  • No credit · 0 of 1
    “Recall is the ability to retrieve information from long-term memory without cues.”

    A textbook definition. It never says how this study measured recall.

  • No credit · 0 of 1
    “Recall was how much each student remembered about sea otters.”

    Tied to the study, but not measurable. "How much" never becomes a number or a scale.

C

Statistic interpretation

1 point

Describe what the difference in mean recall after one week (56% vs. 42%) indicates.

Describe: say what the number means for the study, not just what it is.

What earns it

  • States the direction: which group was higher or lower, or which way a correlation runs.
  • Connects the number to the variables in the study ("the practice-test group remembered more of the passage").
  • When the prompt says the result was (or was not) statistically significant, says what that means: the difference is unlikely (or could be) due to chance.

What doesn't

  • Restating the numbers with no meaning ("The means were 56% and 42%").
  • Defining the statistic in general ("A mean is the average").
  • Getting the direction backward, or treating a nonsignificant difference as a real effect.

How to approach it

  1. Name the two groups and say which one scored higher on the measure, in plain words.
  2. Translate the measure back into behavior: "recalled more of the passage," "reported more anxiety."
  3. Check the results paragraph for significance (p < .05). Significant: "unlikely to be due to chance." Not significant: "could be due to chance, so we cannot conclude the groups truly differ."
  4. For a correlation: positive means the two variables rise together; negative means one rises as the other falls. Never say "causes."

5-minute drill: Read the Numbers →

Sentence frames

  • The difference in means indicates that the ________ group ________ (more / less) than the ________ group, and because it was statistically significant, the difference is unlikely to be due to chance.
  • The correlation of r = ___ indicates that as ________ increased, ________ tended to ________ .
  • Because the difference was not statistically significant, it could be due to chance, so the study cannot conclude that ________ .

Scored examples

  • Full credit · 1 of 1
    “It indicates that after a week, students who took a practice test remembered more of the passage than students who restudied, and because the difference was significant, it is unlikely to be due to chance.”

    Direction, meaning in terms of the study, and what significance means. The significance piece is not always required, but it makes the answer safe.

  • No credit · 0 of 1
    “The practice-test group had a mean of 56% and the restudy group had a mean of 42%.”

    Restates the numbers. This was the most common way to miss Part C in 2025.

  • No credit · 0 of 1
    “The mean is the average score of each group, so it shows the average recall.”

    Defines a mean in general and never says what the difference shows.

D

Ethical guideline

1 point

Identify one ethical guideline applied by the researchers and describe how they applied it.

Identify the guideline, then describe the step the researchers took. (The 2026 exam asked for both.)

What earns it

  • Names a guideline the summary says the researchers applied: informed consent, right to withdraw, debriefing, protection from harm, confidentiality, or approval by an institutional review board (IRB).
  • Points to what the researchers did ("each participant read and signed a consent form describing the procedures").

What doesn't

  • A guideline the summary never mentions. Readers treat it as contradicting your answer, even if it is a real guideline.
  • A guideline the researchers should have used but did not.
  • Study features that are not ethical guidelines: random assignment, course credit, payment, a large sample.
  • General statements ("The study was ethical").

How to approach it

  1. Use only what you starred while reading. If the summary does not say it, do not write it.
  2. Pick the clearest one. One correct guideline is the whole point; listing several only adds chances to contradict yourself.
  3. Write the guideline, then the specific step from the study.

Sentence frames

  • The researchers applied ________ when they ________ .
  • One ethical guideline was ________ ; the summary says participants ________ .

Scored examples

  • Full credit · 1 of 1
    “The researchers applied informed consent: before the study, each participant signed a form describing the procedures and stating they could withdraw at any time.”

    A guideline the summary states, and the step the researchers took.

  • No credit · 0 of 1
    “The researchers kept participants’ information confidential.”

    Confidentiality is a real guideline, but this summary never mentions it. In 2025, guidelines not stated in the study were the main reason students missed Part D.

  • No credit · 0 of 1
    “The study was ethical because students got course credit.”

    Course credit is a reward, not an ethical guideline.

E

Generalizability

1 point

Explain the extent to which the research findings may or may not be generalizable using specific and relevant evidence from the study.

Explain: make a claim about a population, then back it with who the participants were.

What earns it

  • Makes a claim about a population: the general population, or a group relevant to the participants (college students, adults, teenagers in other countries).
  • Supports it with specific participant details from the study: age, location, school, gender, how they were recruited, culture, species or breed.
  • If you say "partly" generalizable, give evidence for both sides.

What doesn't

  • A claim with no population ("The study is generalizable").
  • Sample size alone ("Only 120 people, so it is not generalizable"). Readers do not accept size, reliability, or validity as the reason.
  • Random assignment as the reason. Random assignment supports cause and effect, not who the results apply to. (Random sampling is what helps generalizability.)

How to approach it

  1. Look at the participants section only. List who they were: age range, where, what school, how recruited, any gender or cultural skew.
  2. Choose a position. "Limited" is usually the strongest.
  3. Name the people the results may not apply to, and tie that to the details you listed.

5-minute drill: Who Does It Apply To? →

Sentence frames

  • The findings may not be generalizable to ________ because the participants were all ________ .
  • The findings may be generalizable to ________ (a population like the sample) because the participants were ________ , but they may not apply to ________ because ________ .

Scored examples

  • Full credit · 1 of 1
    “The findings are limited. Every participant was an 18- to 22-year-old in an intro psychology course at one public university in Missouri, so the results may not apply to younger students, older adults, or students at other kinds of schools.”

    A position, a population, and specific participant details that explain the limit.

  • No credit · 0 of 1
    “The study is not generalizable because 120 people is too small a sample.”

    Sample size alone is not accepted, and no population is named.

  • No credit · 0 of 1
    “The findings are generalizable because participants were randomly assigned.”

    Random assignment is about cause and effect inside the study, not about who the results apply to.

F

Argumentation

2 points

Explain how at least one of the research findings supports or refutes the researchers’ hypothesis that retrieval practice improves long-term retention.

Explain, worth 2 points: a specific result, accurately interpreted, plus how it supports or refutes the hypothesis.

What earns it

  • 2 points: uses a specific result from the study, interprets it accurately, and explains how it supports or refutes the hypothesis or concept.
  • 1 point: gives a result but never explains the connection; or explains the connection without any result; or interprets the result partly wrong; or claims the result proves cause when the method cannot show cause.

What doesn't

  • "It supports the hypothesis" with no result and no reasoning.
  • Misreading the results (wrong group, wrong direction, ignoring that a difference was not significant).

How to approach it

  1. Pick the finding that fits the hypothesis most directly, and quote its numbers.
  2. Say what it shows in plain words.
  3. Then the reasoning sentence: what about this result matches (or contradicts) what the hypothesis predicted? Use the concept named in the prompt.
  4. Watch the method: a correlation can support "is related to," not "causes."

5-minute drill: Evidence + Because →

Sentence frames

  • The researchers found that ________ (specific result with numbers). This supports / refutes the hypothesis that ________ because ________ .
  • One finding is ________ . This shows ________ , which is what ________ (the concept) predicts, because ________ .

Scored examples

  • Full credit · 2 of 2
    “After one week, the practice-test group recalled 56% of the key ideas compared with 42% for the restudy group, a significant difference. This supports the hypothesis because both groups spent the same time with the passage; the only difference was that one group practiced retrieving it, and that group kept more of it in long-term memory a week later.”

    A specific result, accurately read, and an explanation of why it fits the hypothesis (same study time, only retrieval differed).

  • Partial credit · 1 of 2
    “The practice-test group recalled 56% after a week and the restudy group recalled 42%.”

    A specific, accurate result, but no explanation of how it supports the hypothesis. Evidence alone earns 1.

  • Partial credit · 1 of 2
    “This supports the hypothesis because testing yourself makes you remember things better than rereading.”

    Reasoning without a result from the study earns 1. Add the 56% vs. 42% finding for the second point.

Traps that cost points

  • Answering from what you know about psychology instead of what the summary says. Nearly every point comes from the text.
  • Listing extra methods, guidelines, or concepts "just in case." A wrong extra contradicts your right answer and costs the point.
  • Restating numbers in C. Say what they mean.
  • Using sample size to answer E.
  • Stopping F after the evidence. The second point is the "because."
  • Writing in bullet points or leaving parts unlabeled. Label A to F and use complete sentences.

Practice sets

Each set is a full, original AAQ with a scoring guide for every part. Answers save in your browser, and you can download a PDF of your work.

Next: The Evidence-Based Question (EBQ) ·Back to FRQ Prep