AP Psychology · Article Analysis Question

AAQ Practice Set 3: Pulling Together, or Not

Plan on 25 minutes: about 10 to read, 15 to write.

  1. Start the timer and work like it's the real exam: 25 minutes, no notes.
  2. Read and highlight the study. Select text, then tap a color.
  3. Write each part, then open its scoring guide (it unlocks once you've written) and tick the checklist honestly.
25:00
0 answered
Part 1Write your response (15 minutes)

Write each part in full, then open its scoring guide (it unlocks once you have written something). Tick only what your answer really does: your self-score adds up at the top.

Check Part A against the scoring guide

Earns it: Experiment. Participants were randomly assigned to one of three conditions, and the researchers manipulated what participants believed about the group and whether their effort could be identified.

Doesn’t: “Naturalistic observation,” “case study,” or naming the method plus a second, wrong one.

Check Part B against the scoring guide

Earns it: The mean force, in kilograms, that a participant pulled on the rope across three 5-second trials, measured by the force meter.

Doesn’t: “How hard they tried,” with no kilograms, trials, or force meter.

Check Part C against the scoring guide

Earns it: When participants believed their own effort would be recorded, they pulled about as hard as people pulling alone. The 1-kg difference could be due to chance, so being identifiable in a group did not reduce effort.

Doesn’t: “The identifiable group pulled 1 kg less, so they loafed a little” (treats a nonsignificant difference as real), or restating 61 and 62.

Check Part D against the scoring guide

Earns it: Debriefing: after the session, the researchers explained that there were no other pullers and why the deception was needed.

Also earns it: Informed consent (written consent from each participant), IRB or ethics committee approval (the university’s research ethics committee approved it), or protection from harm (people with back or shoulder injuries were excluded).

Doesn’t: “Deception” as the guideline. Deception is a research technique; debriefing is the guideline that makes it acceptable. Payment is not a guideline.

Check Part E against the scoring guide

Earns it: Limited. All participants were 18- to 24-year-old university students in Osaka, Japan, a collectivist culture, so the size of the loafing effect may differ for people in individualist cultures, for older adults, or for groups doing real work like sports teams.

Also earns it: Partly generalizable to young adults, since men and women were nearly evenly represented, but limited by one university in one country.

Doesn’t: “Only 90 participants,” or “the rope task wasn’t realistic” with no reference to who the participants were.

Check Part F against the scoring guide (2 points)

Earns it: Point 1: a specific result. Participants who believed they were pulling in a group where only the total was recorded pulled 51 kg on average, significantly less than the 62 kg pulled by those who believed they were alone. Point 2: the explanation. Everyone actually pulled alone, so the only difference was the belief that their effort was hidden in a group, and that belief lowered effort, which is social loafing.

Also earns it: Using the identifiable condition (61 kg, no significant difference from alone) to show that loafing disappears when individual effort can be identified, which supports the specific hypothesis.

Doesn’t: Describing social loafing with no result (1 point), or citing the numbers with no explanation (1 point).

Under 5 of 7? Reread the part cards on the AAQ page for the parts you missed, or try a 5-minute drill.

Part 2Would it earn the point?
1.Which answer to Part D earns the point?

2.Which Part E answer would earn the point?

3.What does the nonsignificant difference between 61 kg and 62 kg tell you?

Save your work

Your PDF has your self-score, every part you wrote, and your self-check results, so it doubles as a study sheet.