Study 1 Hypothesis: background music impairs reading comprehension. Students were randomly assigned to read in silence, with instrumental music, or with music that had lyrics.
Mean comprehension: silence 82%, instrumental 80%, lyrics 68%. Lyrics vs. silence was statistically significant; instrumental vs. silence was not.
Prompt: Explain how at least one finding supports or refutes the hypothesis.
1. A student wrote: “The silence group scored 82% and the lyrics group scored 68%.”
1. How does this response score?a. 2 points: a specific result, accurately explained b. 1 point: a result, but no explanation c. 1 point: an explanation, but no specific result d. 1 point: a result that is misread or treated as proof of cause
2. A student wrote: “This supports the hypothesis because music with words competes with reading for your attention.”
2. How does this response score?a. 2 points: a specific result, accurately explained b. 1 point: a result, but no explanation c. 1 point: an explanation, but no specific result d. 1 point: a result that is misread or treated as proof of cause
3. A student wrote: “The lyrics group scored 68%, significantly lower than the silence group’s 82%. Since the groups differed only in what they heard, music with lyrics hurt comprehension, which supports the hypothesis.”
3. How does this response score?a. 2 points: a specific result, accurately explained b. 1 point: a result, but no explanation c. 1 point: an explanation, but no specific result d. 1 point: a result that is misread or treated as proof of cause
4. A student wrote: “The instrumental group scored 80% compared with 82%, which proves all music hurts reading.”
4. How does this response score?a. 2 points: a specific result, accurately explained b. 1 point: a result, but no explanation c. 1 point: an explanation, but no specific result d. 1 point: a result that is misread or treated as proof of cause
5. A student wrote: “The instrumental group (80%) did not differ significantly from silence (82%), which partly refutes the hypothesis: music without lyrics did not impair comprehension, so it may be the words, not music itself.”
5. How does this response score?a. 2 points: a specific result, accurately explained b. 1 point: a result, but no explanation c. 1 point: an explanation, but no specific result d. 1 point: a result that is misread or treated as proof of cause
Study 2 Hypothesis: volunteering is related to greater life satisfaction. Researchers surveyed 1,000 adults. Result: hours of volunteering and life satisfaction were positively correlated, r = +.30, statistically significant.
6. A student wrote: “Volunteering causes people to be more satisfied with life (r = +.30), which supports the hypothesis.”
6. How does this response score?a. 2 points: a specific result, accurately explained b. 1 point: a result, but no explanation c. 1 point: an explanation, but no specific result d. 1 point: a result that is misread or treated as proof of cause
7. A student wrote: “People who volunteered more tended to report higher life satisfaction (r = +.30). That is the positive relationship the hypothesis predicted, so the finding supports it.”
7. How does this response score?a. 2 points: a specific result, accurately explained b. 1 point: a result, but no explanation c. 1 point: an explanation, but no specific result d. 1 point: a result that is misread or treated as proof of cause
8. A student wrote: “This supports the hypothesis because helping others makes people feel good about themselves.”
8. How does this response score?a. 2 points: a specific result, accurately explained b. 1 point: a result, but no explanation c. 1 point: an explanation, but no specific result d. 1 point: a result that is misread or treated as proof of cause
Clear the self-check answers in this part and try again