Unit 5A · Memory · Reading 9 of 12
Rebuilding the Past
Before you read
Imagine you witnessed a robbery. A police officer asks, "What color was the getaway car?" Would that question make you more likely to "remember" a getaway car, even if there wasn't one?
Words you'll own by the end
- Schema: a mental framework of expectations, built from past experience.
- Constructive memory: filling in gaps in memory with what you expect, so memory is rebuilt rather than replayed.
- Eyewitness recall: what witnesses to an event remember, and how reliable it is.
- Framing: the way a question is worded, which can change the answer.
- Misinformation effect: misremembering an event because of misleading information introduced afterward.
1. Memory is rebuilt, not replayed
A memory isn't a video you play back. Each time you remember, your brain rebuilds the event from pieces, a bit like a jigsaw puzzle with some pieces missing. To fill the gaps, it uses schemas: frameworks of expectations built from experience. You have a schema for a doctor's office, a classroom, a birthday party.
Schemas help you make sense of things fast, but they can also make you "remember" what you expected instead of what happened. That's constructive memory. If you got a shot last week, you might describe the nurse the way you picture a typical nurse rather than how that person actually looked.
Check-in: People wait about half a minute in a professor's office. Later, many say they saw books on the shelves, but there were none. Why?
2. Why eyewitnesses get it wrong
Research on eyewitness recall has made psychologists question how much the legal system trusts testimony. Witnesses can:
- Use schemas to fill in what "usually" happens in a robbery or a crash.
- Be swayed by expectations (a perceptual set) during a stressful, emotional event.
- Reshape each other's memories by talking afterward. Instead of helping, they can blend in each other's details.
- Be shaped by the questions they're asked. "Which hand was the gun in?" assumes there was a gun before anyone said so. An open question, "What did you see?", doesn't.
3. Loftus and Palmer: one word changes the memory
Elizabeth Loftus and John Palmer (1974) showed people videos of car accidents. Everyone saw the same video. Then they were asked, "About how fast were the cars going when they ___ each other?" Only the verb changed. This is framing.
| Verb in the question | Average speed estimate |
|---|---|
| smashed | 40.8 mph |
| collided | 39.3 mph |
| bumped | 38.1 mph |
| hit | 34.0 mph |
| contacted | 31.8 mph |
In a second experiment, a week later, people were asked, "Did you see any broken glass?" There was no broken glass in the video. But people who had heard "smashed" were more than twice as likely to say yes (32%) as people who had heard "hit" (14%) or no speed question at all (12%). The word didn't just change the estimate. It changed what people "saw."
That's the misinformation effect: misleading information introduced after an event gets blended into the memory of the event itself.
Textbook correction: the book says the broken-glass question compared "smashed" with "contacted." In the broken-glass experiment, the groups were "smashed," "hit," and a group asked no speed question.
Try it: Schema, framing, or misinformation?
What's distorting each memory?
A detective asks, "How tall was the man with the scar?" and the witness, who never noticed a scar, later remembers one.
Asked "How short was the suspect?", witnesses give lower heights than when asked "How tall?"
Recalling a fast-food visit, you remember a menu board above the counter, though this place used a touchscreen.
After reading a news story that says the getaway car was red, a witness who saw a blue car now remembers red.
Am I ready for a pop quiz?
Check a box only if you can say the answer out loud without scrolling up.
Come back to your "before you read" question
Back to the getaway car. Explain how the officer's question could plant a memory, using framing and misinformation effect. How should the officer have asked?