← All Unit 5A readings

Unit 5A · Memory · Reading 8 of 12

Getting It Back

Read before: Day 4Time: about 6 minutesTextbook: Ch. 7, Retrieval: recall, recognition, tip of the tongue, priming (pp. 151–153)

Before you read

Which is easier: a fill-in-the-blank test or a multiple-choice test on the same material? Why do you think so?

Words you'll own by the end

  • Recall: pulling information out of memory with few or no cues, like a fill-in-the-blank or essay question.
  • Recognition: picking out the right answer from options, like a multiple-choice question.
  • Relearning: learning something a second time; faster relearning shows some memory was kept.
  • Tip-of-the-tongue phenomenon: feeling sure you know something but being unable to pull it out.
  • Priming: activating memories through a cue, often without awareness.

1. When retrieval is the problem

Sometimes a memory was encoded and stored just fine, and you still can't get it out. That's a retrieval problem. The classic example is the tip-of-the-tongue phenomenon: you know you know the actor's name, you can almost feel it, maybe you even know the first letter, but it won't come. It often pops up later when you stop trying, which shows it was stored all along.

2. Three ways to measure memory

How much you seem to remember depends on how you're asked.

Recall, recognition, relearning
MeasureWhat you doExample
RecallRetrieve it with few cues"Define encoding." Fill in the blank. Essay.
RecognitionIdentify the right answer among choicesA multiple-choice question; picking a suspect from a lineup
RelearningLearn it again and see how much faster it goesRelearning Spanish vocab you "forgot" from 8th grade, in half the time

Most people find recognition easier than recall, though it depends on the question and how well you know the material. A classic study by Harry Bahrick and colleagues (1975) tested people on their high school classmates. Years after graduation, people could still pick out classmates' names and faces from yearbook photos about 90% of the time, even 15 years later. But when asked to simply list classmates' names from memory (recall), they did far worse, and recall kept dropping over the decades.

Textbook note: the book reports "about 75%" recognition and "about 25%" recall at 25 years. Bahrick's published numbers are a little different, but the pattern is the same: recognition holds up far better than recall.

Relearning is the most sensitive measure of all. Even when you can't recall or recognize something, you may relearn it faster the second time. That "savings" proves some memory survived. You'll see how Hermann Ebbinghaus used this method in Reading 10.

Try it: Recall, recognition, or relearning?

Which measure of memory is each one?

A short-answer question: "Name the three stores in the Atkinson-Shiffrin model."

Choosing "echoic memory" from five answer choices.

Re-memorizing the state capitals takes you 20 minutes this year; it took 2 hours in 5th grade.

A witness picks the robber out of a six-person lineup.

3. Priming: memory you didn't know you were using

Priming means a cue activates information already in storage. You can't remember the words to a song, but the moment the first few notes play, the lyrics come rushing back. Staring at the spot on the board where your teacher wrote something, while trying to remember it on a test, is an attempt to prime the memory.

Priming can work even without awareness, which makes it a kind of implicit memory. In research with patients who had damage to the hippocampus, people were shown a list of words and later couldn't recall any of them. But when asked to say the first word that came to mind starting with "ch," they were more likely to say a word from the list, like "charter." They had no idea why that word came to mind.

Check-in: After seeing a list that included "table," a patient with amnesia can't recall the list. Asked for the first word starting with "tab," he says "table." What does this show?

Am I ready for a pop quiz?

Check a box only if you can say the answer out loud without scrolling up.

Come back to your "before you read" question

Back to fill-in-the-blank vs. multiple choice. Use recall and recognition to explain which is usually easier and why. Then name one way a multiple-choice question could still be hard.