Unit 5A · Memory · Reading 11 of 12
Interference and Motivated Forgetting
Before you read
Have you ever changed a password, then kept typing the old one? Or called a new teacher by your old teacher's name?
Words you'll own by the end
- Interference: forgetting because other, similar information gets in the way.
- Proactive interference: old information interferes with recalling new information.
- Retroactive interference: new information interferes with recalling old information.
- Motivated forgetting: forgetting things because we don't want to remember them.
- Repression: Freud's term for pushing painful memories out of conscious awareness.
1. Interference: it's not gone, it's crowded
Sometimes information isn't lost. It's confused with something similar. That's interference, and it comes in two directions:
| Proactive interference | Retroactive interference | |
|---|---|---|
| Direction | Old blocks new | New blocks old |
| Example | Junior year, you keep spinning your sophomore locker combination. | By spring, you can't remember last year's combination, because this year's took its place. |
| Example | You type your old password into the new login. | Months after the change, you can't remember the old password. |
| Memory trick | Proactive = Past interfering | Retroactive = Recent interfering |
Teachers who meet hundreds of students a year show retroactive interference all the time. When a former student visits, the teacher may call him by his younger sibling's name, because the newer name is crowding out the older one.
A tip: "retro" means looking back, like retro music. In retroactive interference, new learning works backward to block old memories.
Try it: Proactive or retroactive?
Which kind of interference is it?
After learning Spanish, Ana keeps mixing Spanish words into her new French class.
After a year of French, Ana can't remember the Spanish words she used to know.
Your family moved, and you keep giving out your old address.
You learned a new dance routine for the spring show and now can't remember the fall routine.
Melinda's old bike needed pedaling to shift gears; on her new bike she keeps pedaling while shifting, and the gears jam.
2. Motivated forgetting and repression
Few of us would choose to remember every embarrassing or painful moment. Sigmund Freud proposed that we push distressing memories so deep into the unconscious that we're no longer aware of them. He called this motivated forgetting, or repression.
Repression is one of the most debated ideas in memory research:
- It's hard to test. How do you prove someone has a memory they can't access?
- It clashes with other findings. Highly emotional events usually get stronger memories, not weaker ones (remember the amygdala). Many Holocaust survivors didn't want to talk about what happened, but they had vivid memories of it.
- "Recovered" memories can be false. Hypnosis and some therapy techniques have led people to "remember" events that never happened. Elizabeth Loftus showed in later research that people can be led to remember childhood events that were invented by the researchers.
The chapter ends with a warning from Loftus: "Just because someone thinks they remember something in detail, with confidence and with emotion, does not mean that it actually happened."
Check-in: Why are many psychologists skeptical of repressed and "recovered" memories?
Am I ready for a pop quiz?
Check a box only if you can say the answer out loud without scrolling up.
Come back to your "before you read" question
Back to the password and the teacher's name. Label each as proactive or retroactive interference, and explain how you decided.