← All Unit 5A readings

Unit 5A · Memory · Reading 2 of 12

Shallow or Deep?

Read before: Day 1Time: about 8 minutesTextbook: Ch. 7, Encoding (pp. 144–146)

Before you read

Think of a song or ad jingle you know by heart even though you never tried to learn it. Now think of a definition you studied hard and still forgot. Why do you think the jingle stuck and the definition didn't?

Words you'll own by the end

  • Effortful processing: encoding that takes attention and conscious work.
  • Automatic processing: encoding that happens without effort or awareness.
  • Shallow processing: encoding something by its surface: how it looks or sounds, or by rote repetition.
  • Deep processing: encoding something by its meaning. It lasts much longer.
  • Visual, acoustic, and semantic encoding: encoding by how something looks, how it sounds, and what it means.
  • Maintenance vs. elaborative rehearsal: repeating information over and over vs. linking it to things you already know.
  • Self-referent learning: connecting new information to your own life.

1. Effortful and automatic

Studying for a test, learning a new friend's name, memorizing physics formulas: these take effortful processing. You have to pay attention and work at it. Formulas don't "magically" get into your memory.

Other things slip in with no effort at all. You remember where a picture was on a textbook page, or the jingle from a commercial you heard once. If someone asks how you know it, you honestly say, "I don't know." That's automatic processing.

You can't control much of what gets in automatically, so focus on what you can control. The more carefully you attend to something, the more likely you are to keep it. If your math teacher walks through a problem while you're texting, you probably won't be able to do the next one yourself. Research keeps showing that people are not the multitaskers they think they are. You can attend to one task or the other, not both at once.

Check-in: Which is the best example of automatic processing?

2. How deep did it go?

Many students try to learn a definition by repeating it to themselves over and over. Say you're learning the hippocampus: "the structure in the limbic system that helps move short-term memories into long-term memory." Repeat, repeat, repeat. That's shallow processing, and the repetition itself is called maintenance rehearsal. It might get you through tomorrow's quiz, but it probably won't last until the AP exam in May. There's no meaning attached.

Deep processing means adding meaning on purpose. Instead of repeating, add imagery, emotion, humor, or a personal connection. For the hippocampus: picture "hippos on campus," a little hippo in your brain deciding which information gets to move into long-term storage. Silly, but it sticks.

3. Three levels: looks, sounds, means

Psychologists describe three kinds of encoding, from shallow to deep:

Three kinds of encoding
KindYou encode...ExampleDepth
Visualhow it looksRemembering a word was in capital letters, or that you turn at the red houseShallowest
Acoustic (phonetic)how it soundsFrench mère (mother) and père (father) sound alike; the alphabet songDeeper
Semanticwhat it means"Renaissance" means rebirth; "hypo" means below, so the hypothalamus sits below the thalamusDeepest

Semantic encoding wins because meaning gives you something to connect to, and connections are what you use to find a memory later.

Try it: Shallow or deep?

Is each study habit shallow or deep processing?

Reading the definition of "echoic memory" ten times in a row.

Explaining "echoic memory" to your little brother using the time he ignored your mom but could still repeat what she said.

Highlighting every bold word in the chapter.

Asking yourself how "retrieval" is like finding a saved file.

4. Elaborative rehearsal and self-reference

Elaborative rehearsal means attaching associations to what you're learning. To remember that Abraham Lincoln was the 16th president, it helps to also know he was from Illinois, led during the Civil War, was the tallest president, and had four sons. Each fact gives you "something to grab onto" when you try to recall him. Thinking about those connections is what makes the memory stronger.

Here's a fun test. Many students who "can't remember" the last ten presidents can name the last ten songs their favorite artist released, plus the band members. They probably spent more time drilling the presidents. The difference is that the songs mean something to them.

That's the idea behind self-referent learning: connect a new term to your life. When you learned sensory adaptation, maybe you thought of walking into a smelly room and not noticing the smell after a few minutes. Your own example is the strongest hook there is.

Check-in: Maya wants to remember the term "automatic processing." Which strategy uses self-referent learning?

Am I ready for a pop quiz?

Check a box only if you can say the answer out loud without scrolling up.

Come back to your "before you read" question

Why did the jingle stick and the definition didn't? Use at least two of these terms: automatic, shallow, deep, maintenance rehearsal, semantic.