By the end of this lab you will be able to…
- Explain why the Framers created the Electoral College.
- Describe the Electoral College as a two-part system: the people vote in November, then electors vote in December.
- Explain how winner-take-all works in each state, and why it means a candidate can win the presidency while losing the national popular vote.
- Take and defend a position: keep the Electoral College, reform it, or replace it with a national popular vote.
Before you start
Your work saves automatically in this browser. At the end you'll copy or print a lab report to turn in on Canvas.
Where did the Electoral College come from?
In the summer of 1787, the delegates at the Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia argued for weeks about one question: who should choose the President? They looked at three options, and none of them made everyone happy.
Option 1: Congress picks
Simple, but delegates worried a President chosen by Congress would owe Congress favors. That would weaken the separation of powers.
Option 2: The people pick
Some, like James Wilson, wanted a direct popular vote. Others worried that in a huge country with slow news, voters would only know their local candidates. Southern delegates also knew they'd lose influence, since enslaved people could not vote.
Option 3: A compromise
The Committee on Postponed Matters proposed electors: each state gets as many as it has members of Congress, and each state decides how to pick them. Article II, Section 1 made it law.
The compromise had strings attached
Because a state's electors = its House seats + its 2 Senators, the Electoral College inherited two other deals from 1787: the Great Compromise (every state gets two Senators, which gives small states a boost) and the Three-Fifths Compromise (enslaved people counted toward House seats, which boosted the power of slaveholding states until the 14th Amendment in 1868).
How it has changed
- 1787Article II creates electors. Originally each elector cast two votes; first place became President, second place became Vice President.
- 1800Thomas Jefferson and his own running mate, Aaron Burr, tie at 73 electoral votes. The House needs 36 ballots to pick Jefferson.
- 1804The 12th Amendment fixes the problem: electors cast separate votes for President and Vice President.
- 1830sAlmost every state has moved to letting citizens vote for electors, usually with winner-take-all, which is still the rule in 48 states today.
- 1961The 23rd Amendment gives Washington, D.C. 3 electors, bringing the total to 538.
- 2020The Supreme Court rules in Chiafalo v. Washington that states may require electors to vote for the candidate who won their state.
- 2022The Electoral Count Reform Act clarifies that the Vice President's job counting votes in Congress is only ceremonial.
Quick check: Origins
How it works: a two-part system
When you vote for President, you are not casting a vote directly for that person. You're voting for a slate of electors who have pledged to support that candidate. The election happens in two parts:
The people vote
On Election Day (the Tuesday after the first Monday in November), voters in each state cast ballots. The candidate who wins the state's popular vote wins that state's slate of electors.
The electors vote
In mid-December, each state's electors meet in their state capital and cast the official votes. On January 6, Congress counts them. A candidate needs a majority, 270, to win.
Where does 538 come from?
Half of 538 is 269, so a candidate needs 270 for a majority. Every state gets at least 3 (1 House seat + 2 Senators), no matter how small. Bigger states get more because they have more House seats.
Winner-take-all: try it
In 48 states and D.C., whoever wins the most votes in the state gets all of its electoral votes, even if they win by one vote. Click the voters below to switch them between Blue and Red. This pretend state has 10 electoral votes.
Notice: 51 Blue votes and 49 Red votes produce the same result as 100 Blue votes and 0 Red votes: 10 to 0. The 49 Red voters earn their candidate nothing.
The two exceptions: Maine and Nebraska use the congressional district method. They give 2 electoral votes to the statewide winner and 1 to the winner of each congressional district, so they can split their votes. (In our game, every state uses winner-take-all.)
The map changes every 10 years
After every census, the 435 House seats are reapportioned (re-divided) among the states by population. Since electoral votes = House seats + 2, the Electoral College map changes too. The 2020 Census changed the map used for the 2024 and 2028 elections:
- Texas +2 (now 40)
- Florida +1 (now 30)
- North Carolina +1 (now 16)
- Colorado +1 (now 10)
- Montana +1 (now 4)
- Oregon +1 (now 8)
- California −1 (now 54)
- New York −1 (now 28)
- Illinois −1 (now 19)
- Pennsylvania −1 (now 19)
- Ohio −1 (now 17)
- Michigan −1 (now 15)
- West Virginia −1 (now 4)
The trend: population, and power, has been shifting from the Northeast and Midwest toward the South and West.
Quick check: How it works
Election Night: Race to 270
Now you'll run your own presidential election. Each state's popular vote is decided by a roll of the dice. Whoever rolls higher wins that state's popular vote, and with it all of the state's electoral votes. First to 270 is projected the winner, but keep counting every state so you can compare the electoral vote to the popular vote.
Set up your election
Play with a partner on one device (take turns), or play against the computer.
Game options (your teacher may tell you which to use)
How are popular votes counted?
Results & Analysis
It's happened in real life, five times
In these elections, the winner of the presidency did not win the most popular votes.
| Year | Won the presidency | Won the popular vote | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1824 | John Quincy Adams | Andrew Jackson | No one won a majority of electors, so the House chose Adams. |
| 1876 | Rutherford B. Hayes | Samuel Tilden | Disputed returns in 3 states were given to Hayes (185–184) in the Compromise of 1877. |
| 1888 | Benjamin Harrison | Grover Cleveland | Cleveland won by about 90,000 votes; Harrison won the electors 233–168. |
| 2000 | George W. Bush | Al Gore | Gore won by about 540,000 votes; Florida, won by 537 votes, gave Bush 271 electors. |
| 2016 | Donald Trump | Hillary Clinton | Clinton won by about 2.9 million votes; Trump won 304 electors to 227. |
Simulator: how often does it happen?
One game is one election. Let the computer run 1,000 elections with the same dice rules you used and count how often the Electoral College winner loses the popular vote.
Analysis questions
The Big Debate: keep it or end it?
More constitutional amendments have been proposed to change or abolish the Electoral College than on any other subject. Here are the strongest arguments on each side.
Keep the Electoral College
- Federalism. The President is chosen by states, matching how the Constitution balances power between the national government and the states.
- Broad coalitions. Candidates can't win by running up huge margins in a few big cities. They need support across many regions.
- Contained disputes. A close election usually means a recount in one or two states. With a national popular vote, a razor-thin race could mean a recount in all 50.
- Small states have a voice. Less-populated states would otherwise be easy to ignore.
- Clear winners. Winner-take-all usually turns a close popular vote into a clear electoral majority, which helps the country accept the result.
Replace it with a national popular vote
- One person, one vote. Wyoming has about 193,000 people per electoral vote; California has about 732,000. A Wyoming voter has roughly 3.8 times the weight.
- The majority should win. Five Presidents have taken office after losing the popular vote, two of them since 2000.
- Swing states get all the attention. Campaigns spend most of their time and money in a handful of competitive states and mostly skip "safe" states like California, Texas, and New York.
- Every vote would count. Under winner-take-all, millions of votes for the losing candidate in each state elect no one, which can discourage turnout.
- Electors are an extra step. "Faithless electors" have occasionally voted against their state's result.
How could it change?
Needs 2/3 of both houses of Congress and 3/4 of the states (38). Very hard: small states would have to vote to give up their advantage.
States agree to give their electors to the national popular vote winner, but only once states totaling 270 join. As of fall 2026, 18 states + D.C. (222 electoral votes) have joined; Virginia joined in 2026.
Any state could switch to the Maine/Nebraska district method or split its electors by percentage, with no amendment needed.
Your position
Turn in your lab
Checklist
Your lab report
Use Copy report and paste it into the Canvas text box, or Print / Save as PDF and upload the file.
Starting over?